Are Curtains Actually Better Insulators Than Shutters?

No, curtains are not necessarily better insulators than shutters. Both can help reduce heat loss through windows, but their effectiveness depends less on whether they are made from fabric or solid panels and more on how well they fit, the materials used and how they interact with the individual window.

Thermal curtains work by adding a layer of insulating fabric between the room and the glass, helping to slow heat transfer. Made-to-measure shutters work differently, creating a fitted barrier around the window opening that can help reduce air movement and provide additional control over light and privacy.

The most effective solution depends on the window itself, the room and how the space is used. While curtains and shutters cannot replace improvements to the window, they can both form part of a wider approach to improving comfort and reducing heat loss.

What Does Insulation Mean When Comparing Curtains And Shutters?

When homeowners ask whether curtains or shutters are better insulators, they are usually considering several related questions:

Which option helps keep warmth inside the room?

Which helps reduce the cold feeling near the window?

Which can make a room feel more comfortable during colder months?

These questions are connected, but they are not exactly the same.

The thermal performance of a window is influenced by factors including the glazing, the frame, the condition of the seals and the way the window has been installed. The Energy Saving Trust identifies windows and doors as important areas to consider when looking at reducing heat loss in the home, alongside measures such as improving insulation and reducing draughts.

Window coverings provide an additional layer rather than replacing the window itself. Their role is to create another barrier between the room and the outside environment.

Both curtains and shutters work partly by creating a layer of relatively still air between the room and the glass. Because trapped air transfers heat less effectively than moving air, reducing circulation around the window can help slow heat loss.

This is why coverage and fit are such important considerations when comparing different window coverings.

How Thermal Curtains Help Improve Comfort

Curtains have been used for generations to make rooms feel warmer, and modern thermal curtains build on this principle by combining layers of fabric with insulating materials.

A well-designed thermal curtain can help reduce heat transfer by creating an additional barrier between the room and the window. The layers within the fabric help trap air, reducing the movement of warmer air towards the colder glass.

However, not all curtains provide the same level of performance. A lightweight decorative curtain will perform very differently from a lined or interlined thermal curtain designed specifically to improve insulation.

The effectiveness of curtains depends on several factors, including:

  • The thickness and construction of the fabric
  • Whether the curtain is lined or interlined
  • How much of the window it covers
  • Whether gaps around the sides and top are minimised
  • How consistently it is used

For example, a curtain that extends beyond the edges of the window and sits close to the floor will generally provide more coverage than one that leaves large areas exposed.

This means thermal curtains can be a practical solution for homeowners who want to improve comfort while retaining the softness and flexibility of traditional window furnishings.

How Thermal Curtains Help Improve Comfort

How Shutters Help Improve Thermal Performance

Shutters take a different approach to improving window comfort. Rather than hanging in front of the window, they are designed around the dimensions and characteristics of each individual opening.

When closed, the panels create a solid barrier between the room and the glass. This can help reduce air movement around the window and create an additional insulating layer.

Historic England recognises internal shutters, alongside other measures such as blinds and curtains, as one of the ways that the thermal performance of existing windows can be improved. This is particularly relevant when considering how to enhance comfort while retaining the character of existing buildings.

One of the advantages of shutters is that they combine this insulating layer with flexibility. Adjustable louvres allow homeowners to control privacy and daylight without needing to fully open or close the covering.

This means shutters can adapt throughout the day, allowing natural light into a room while still maintaining privacy or reducing direct sunlight when required.

How Shutters Help Improve Thermal Performance

Why Fit Matters More Than The Material Alone

When comparing curtains and shutters, it is easy to focus on the material. However, the way a window covering fits the space can be just as important.

A window covering is most effective when it has been designed with the specific window in mind.

For curtains, this means considering the size of the fabric, the position of the track or pole and the amount of coverage around the window.

For shutters, this means accurate measurement and installation so that the panels are designed to suit the individual window rather than relying on a standard size or generic fit.

This is why two similar window coverings can perform differently in practice. A carefully considered solution will always provide a better result than one that leaves unnecessary gaps or does not properly suit the window it is intended to cover.

Curtains Or Shutters: Which Option Is Right For Your Home?

There is no single answer that applies to every home. Both curtains and shutters can help improve comfort, but they offer different benefits.

Consideration Curtains Shutters
Thermal performance Depends on fabric construction, lining and coverage Depends on design, fit and installation
Window coverage Usually sits in front of the window Designed around the individual window
Light control Generally open or closed Adjustable control through louvres
Appearance Soft furnishing with a wide choice of fabrics and styles Permanent window feature designed around the space
Long-term flexibility Easy to change as interiors evolve Designed as a lasting feature of the home

 

Curtains may be the preferred option for homeowners who want:

  • A softer decorative finish
  • A wide choice of fabrics, colours and patterns
  • The ability to update their interior style more easily

Shutters may be the preferred option for homeowners looking for:

  • A fitted solution designed around their windows
  • Greater control over privacy and daylight
  • A permanent alternative to traditional window coverings

The important consideration is not simply choosing between fabric and shutters. It is selecting a solution that works with the window, the room and the way the space is used.

Can You Use Curtains And Shutters Together?

Many homeowners combine both options to achieve different benefits. Shutters can provide everyday control over privacy, light and the appearance of the window, while curtains can add softness and an additional insulating layer when closed.

Layering window coverings can provide greater flexibility, particularly for homeowners who want different solutions at different times of the day.

The right approach depends on personal preference and how the room is used.

Can you combine shutters and curtains?

So, are curtains actually better insulators than shutters?

Not necessarily. Both can improve the comfort of a room when they are correctly selected, fitted and used.

Thermal curtains can provide an effective additional barrier when they are designed and installed well. Bespoke shutters offer a different approach by creating a fitted, adjustable covering designed specifically around the window.

Ultimately, the performance of any window covering comes down to understanding the window itself. Factors such as the design, fit and installation all influence how effectively a solution helps improve comfort.

This is why made-to-measure window coverings remain important. By considering the individual characteristics of each window, homeowners can choose a solution that balances thermal performance, light control and the overall design of their home.

If you are considering bespoke shutters and would like advice on how they could work with your windows, the London Interior Shutters team can help you explore the options available and explain the factors that influence performance.

Daniel Savva
About the Author
Daniel Savva

Daniel Savva, founder of London Interior Shutters and a true master of his craft, brings over 20 years of expertise in shutter design and installation. Starting as an installer, he worked his way up to Head Installation Manager at a large national organisation before establishing London’s leading shutter company. With an unmatched depth of knowledge, Daniel knows shutters inside and out—he could probably build one blindfolded!

Recent Blog posts

How to Repair Window Shutters

How to Repair Window Shutters

Most common window shutter faults can be repaired without replacing the whole installation. Learn ho...

What Is Solar Gain Through Windows?

What Is Solar Gain Through Windows?

...

Do Window Coverings Keep Rooms Cooler In Summer?

Do Window Coverings Keep Rooms Cooler In Summer?

...

Why Do Windows Lose Heat? The Biggest Causes Explained

Why Do Windows Lose Heat? The Biggest Causes Explained

...

Shutters for London’s Victorian Homes

Shutters for London’s Victorian Homes

...

Do Shutters Add Value to a Home? Property Value and Buyer Appeal Explained

Do Shutters Add Value to a Home? Property Value and Buyer Appeal Explained

...